November 16, 2026
Jennifer Osborn
Director and State Designee
California Department of Industrial Relations
1750 Howe Avenue, Suite 130
Sacramento, CA 95825
Director Osborn:
The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) carefully reviewed the proposed prohibition by the California Division of Occupational Safety and Health (Cal/OSHA) on the fabrication and installation of artificial stone containing more than one percent crystalline silica. OSHA understands California is experiencing a substantial increase in silicosis cases among artificial stone countertop fabrication workers. The number of confirmed cumulative cases increased from 52 through 2022 to 531 by early 2026, a tenfold increase in over three years1. However, we are not aware of a comparative increase in any other jurisdictions during that timeframe. While we acknowledge the seriousness and severity of the silicosis problem, OSHA believes the prohibition of engineered stone is an excessive and unnecessary action.
We recognize that stakeholders have raised legitimate concerns regarding the proposed prohibition. These concerns reflect real implementation challenges that warrant serious consideration. First, a categorical prohibition treats compliant and non-compliant operations identically. An operation that has invested in continuous wet methods, High-Efficiency Particulate Air (HEPA) vacuums, full-face powered air-purifying respirators, and active medical surveillance would face the same ban as an operation with no controls. This approach eliminates any incentive for employers to invest in and improve safety compliance.
Second, California does not control the entire supply chain (imports, manufacture, and sale) for engineered stone. Cal/OSHA can only regulate sites of employment. If artificial stone remains available in the legal market, some non-compliant shops may move underground, concentrating on risk in the least regulated settings. Rather than adopt a categorical prohibition, OSHA strongly urges Cal/OSHA to implement a much more comprehensive and targeted strategy to address exposures and implement preventive measures.
We believe that Cal/OSHA should consider increasing allocations for Health Compliance Officers, especially in the Los Angeles area. When appropriate, Cal/OSHA should use available statutory authority to address violations of required engineering controls. The goal should be to secure proactive abatement, issue Orders Prohibiting Use without delay when required safeguards are absent, refer willful violations resulting in worker fatality for criminal prosecution, and publicize enforcement outcomes to strengthen market incentives for compliance.
Cal/OSHA should also take a much more deliberate approach to employer and employee education. Partnerships with industry stakeholders to systemically address non-compliant workplaces and promote best practices help reduce potential exposure. This approach will create incentives for responsible businesses to invest in compliance and differentiate themselves in the marketplace.
California's state data reveals the inadequacy of resources allocated to appropriate enforcement and education strategies. Cal/OSHA has inspected only 135 shops, approximately 10 percent of the known 1,342 fabrication operations statewide. Of the 127 closed inspections, 120 (94 percent) resulted in citations for violations, and 20 percent of inspected shops required emergency Orders Prohibiting Use. This demonstrates Cal/OSHA has authority to identify hazards and halt operations immediately when imminent hazards are present.
A categorical prohibition will not solve this problem but may even exacerbate it. Cal/OSHA would need to expend as many, or more, resources inspecting for compliance with the one percent standard than it does under existing rules. Effective prevention begins with rigorous implementation and enforcement of existing standards and guidance. In addition, the combination of OSHA's Respirable Crystalline Silica Standard2, National Emphasis Program – Respirable Crystalline Silic3, and the Focus Inspection Initiative4 have proven to be workable in other industries. These should be used as models for Cal/OSHA's adoption and use.
OSHA urges Cal/OSHA to adopt a targeted enforcement strategy that protects workers, rewards compliance, and holds violators accountable. OSHA stands ready to support this shared goal.
David L. Keeling
Assistant Secretary
1 petition-609-Ca lOSHAeval.pdf
2 29 CFR 1910.1053
3 National Emphasis Program – Respirable Crystalline Silica, February 4, 2020 (or the RCS NEP) CPL 03-00-023
4 Respirable Crystalline Silica Focused Inspection Initiative in the Engineered Stone Fabrication and Installation Industries